Scary Puzzles
newest | popular
Get into the spooky spirit with our carefully curated selection of Halloween themed puzzles.
-
FEATURED
Alfred Hitchcock Mystery Magazine Subscription - 6 Issues$34.97 -
FEATURED
Pressman Unsolved Case Files: Harmony Ashcroft - Murder Mystery Game$26.97 -
MasterPieces Seek & Find Jigsaw Puzzle - Halloween Surprise - 1000 Piece$16.99 -
ON SALE
MasterPieces Glow in the Dark Halloween Jigsaw Puzzle - Scared Silly - 500 Piece$8.99 -
MasterPieces Glow in the Dark Halloween Jigsaw Puzzle - If You Dare - 1000 Piece$16.99 -
MasterPieces Glow in the Dark Halloween Jigsaw Puzzle - Fright Night - 500 Piece$14.99 -
MasterPieces Halloween Jigsaw Puzzle - A Scary Night Outside - 1000 Piece$16.99 -
MasterPieces Holiday Glow in the Dark Jigsaw Puzzle - Halloween Terrors - 500 Piece$16.99 -
MasterPieces #Selfies Jigsaw Puzzle - Spooky Smiles Kids - 200 Piece$12.99 -
Booo-opoly (Halloween)$24.99 -
Glow in the Dark Halloween - All Hallow's Eve Jigsaw Puzzle - 500 Piece$16.99 -
MasterPieces Halloween Glow Jigsaw Puzzle - Glow in The Dark - Trick or Treat - 500 Piece$14.99 -
ON SALE
MasterPieces Scrumptious Jigsaw Puzzle - Halloween Treats - 1000 Piece$13.59 -
MasterPieces Halloween Jigsaw Puzzle - Three Little Witches - 1000 Piece$16.99 -
MasterPieces Halloween Jigsaw Puzzle - Haunted House on the Hill - 1000 Piece$16.99 -
MasterPieces Halloween Glow Glow in the Dark Halloween Jigsaw Puzzle - A Dark Brew - 500 Piece$14.99 -
MasterPieces A-Maze-ing Jigsaw Puzzle - Halloween Night - 500 Piece$14.99 -
ON SALE
MasterPieces Halloween Jigsaw Puzzle - Lucky Thirteen - 1000 Piece$13.59 -
MasterPieces Holiday Halloween Jigsaw Puzzle - The Tag Along - 1000 Piece$16.99 -
Ellery Queen Mystery Magazine Subscription - 6 Issues$34.97 -
House of Horrors Jigsaw Puzzle - 1000 Piece$23.39 -
Pressman Unsolved Case Files: Jamie Banks - Murder Mystery Game$26.97 -
Killer Trivia Game - The Best Murder Mystery Party Game$25.99 -
Hunt A Killer - Death at the Dive Bar - Immersive Murder Mystery Game$26.99